Why we need to change our thinking about the pandemic: virus variants, vaccination, divisiveness
Sustainability, Adaptation, and Regenerative Farming: Understanding Responses to Global Warming

What is in a Street Name?

Amherst cropTime for more inclusive street names in Davis

 By Colin Walsh

Since George Floyd’s death just over a year ago, Americans have taken to the streets raising their voices against racial oppression. A new desire to reckon with racism has arisen in our country. One form this has taken is in reevaluating the naming of buildings and places though this reevaluation of names also predates the rise of the BLM movement. For example, in 2017 Yale changed the name of one of its residential colleges which had been named after Vice President Calhoun, an infamous white supremacist. The University of Virginia renamed its law school away from that of a former confederate general. Closer to home UC Berkeley renamed 2 of its buildings in 2020 to move away from the names of former faculty members with slave holding ties or well documented white supremacist views. (link)

Sometimes this has been controversial. In San Francisco the school district recently voted to rename 44 public schools, but then later rescinded the decision.

A few years ago in Davis we debated the appropriateness of “Sutter Place”, and ultimately renamed part of it to Risling Court after David Risling Jr. a civil rights activist and founder of DQ University (link). But, the City left both Bidwell street and place, named after John Bidwell, Sutter’s business manager. The Davis Sutter Hospital also still lists its address as Sutter Place. 

Clearly street names with a problematic legacy are not easy or quick to change, but it is time we look hard at the names of other streets and institutions in Davis. This would be an excellent job for the Historical Resource Management Commission, or a specially appointed committee. In the meantime, here is my first look at the subject. We have a few problematic street names in Davis and some serious issues of omission.

Covell Blvd. and Covell Place are both named for C.A. Covell. "At the Council meeting of June 7, 1943 Mayor Covell expressed his support for Army General DeWitt's proposal not to allow Japanese nationals or citizens to return to California after the war. It died for lack of a second." (John Lofland, Davis: Radical Changes, Deep Constants p.118) Then, "Mayor Covell called a special meeting for June 21 in which to consider a revision that applied only to Japanese nationals. it was adopted unanimously by the four members present." (Lofland, p.118) Covell also supported anti-Asian legislation in 1940 when he backed a Chamber of Commerce proposal to enact laws making it more difficult for "Oriental" retailers to do business in Davis (Lofland, p.117). That certainly seems like enough to cause some serious reevaluation.

There are other streets named for local historical figures that I have not researched; it is something worth doing.

In Davis we have several neighborhoods that have streets named after universities. Amherst is one such street that has a problematic name. Amherst is named after a college that is named after a town that is named after Lord Jeffery Amherst, a former British general who proposed giving smallpox blankets to Native Americans during the 7 year war. In 2015 Amherst college voted to no longer have Lord Jeff Amherst as its mascot (link). It has also been proposed that the town of Amherst change its name. It is worth Davis reevaluating the name of this short street.

Citadel is named for Citadel College in South Carolina, a military College that didn’t admit women until 1995. 10 years later 1 in 5 female Citadel cadets reported being sexualy assaulted. (link) Does this warrant a change? Is it what we want to honor in our community? It probably at least warrants evaluation.

There may be other problematic street names but these are the ones I know about. There are likely more that warrant reconsideration. Even this act of discussion and reconsideration is a positive step towards reconciliation.

On the bright side, in researching Davis street names I found that Humboldt Ave is named for Humboldt County which is named for Humboldt Bay which was named for Alexander von Humboldt, a widely admired scientist and naturalist of the 1800’s who vocally criticized slavery in the U.S. (link)

What came to strike me most about Davis’s street names is not so much the few streets with problematic origins – it is that large parts of town are named for private colleges and universities, many of which were predominantly or exclusively white and male for much of their history. Racism is not always a commission of specific acts. Prejudice and discrimination can take the quieter form of omission. There is an omission here in Davis.

To be fair, Radcliff, Sweet Briar, Simmons, Wellesley, Mills and Scripps are all historically women’s colleges though they are the minority among the street names.

The bigger question is, where is Morehouse, Spellman, Xavier, and Howard and or other historically black universities? (Howard Way on the UCD Campus is named for Walter L. Howard, the founder of the UC Davis Pomology department). Grambling Court is the only street in Davis that I am aware of that is named for a historically black school and it is a tiny isolated cul de sac most people have probably missed. There is a serious omission here. 

Considering one of the first tribal colleges or universities was located between Davis and Winters, one might expect a DQ way, or Diné College, place. These names are missing too. There is a Navajo street named for Navajo national monument in the national park street neighborhood. Interestingly there is a discussion in the Navajo tribe as to what is the better name, Navajo or Diné (link). Naming a street or streets for tribal college would be a stronger statement.

There are likely other colleges and universities that warrant inclusion as potential street names as well. It is worth further consideration.

We can do better here. We can demonstrate inclusivity by naming streets in new developments like Bretton Woods and Nishi with more inclusive names.  

While we are discussing names, let's not ignore how ludicrous it is that the Davis City Council is allowing a portion of the community to be named for a monetary management system begun in 1944 establishing the US dollar as the dominant international currency. (link) This name is completely out of step with other neighborhood names in Davis and should be changed as soon as possible before any of the project is built.

Renaming a development before ground is broken, and naming new streets to demonstrate inclusivity is easier than renaming existing streets. It is a good and easy place to start and the City Council can take action right away to set this in motion. Looking at renaming existing streets is more difficult but is certainly worth further investigation at a minimum. 

 

 

 

 

 

Comments

Ron O

"Sometimes this has been controversial. In San Francisco the school district recently voted to rename 44 public schools, but then later rescinded the decision."

That was a disaster, and would lead to a broader discussion regarding a more-significant controversy regarding one of the school board members (and a related recall effort), there. Including the abandonment of "merit-based enrollments" at the top public high school in San Francisco, which primarily "benefits" Asians. That is, if one is to define merit-based enrollments as a "benefit" (rather than something "earned"), in the first place.

Truth be told, few even know why streets and other public facilities were named after a given individual in the first place (especially as time goes by), with the exception of those such as "Lincoln" high school. (Which was one of the name changes, by the San Francisco school district.)

Ron O

Here's another one, where most people don't know "who" he is/was, and (sadly-to-say?) may not even care in the first place.

John Barovetto Park

https://www.cityofdavis.org/Home/Components/FacilityDirectory/FacilityDirectory/32/2926?npage=3

I prefer names such as "Mace Ranch Park" (though that begs the question of who "Mace" was), "Central Park", "Slide Hill Park", etc. In any case, names that mean something on a more permanent basis, and/or perhaps actually relate to their location.

I'd generally avoid names of individuals, especially if they have no direct relationship to the immediate area. For that matter, that might include "Lincoln".

How about "Delta Breeze Park"? (Sounds pleasant/local enough.) But would suggest avoiding "Delta Variant Park".

Colin

one post script note. the artist name streets of the Green Meadows and Wild Horse sections of Davis also have a serious omission problem.

Aaron Wedra

Thank you for your research and history lesson Colin. Much respect for your courage in addressing this topic.

Russell

Along with the changing of Ghandi's statue changing street names has many pitfalls. Assigning new street name to include historical figures that were once overlooked would be better than changing existing street names. One could argue that erasing the racial, social, and economic prejudges minimizes the struggle that those who came before had to overcome to bring the subject to light. And taken to extremes can result in historically significant things being obliterate at the detriment to society as a whole.
https://www.nationalgeographic.com/history/article/150901-isis-destruction-looting-ancient-sites-iraq-syria-archaeology

Lauren Ayers

Sacramento has a Kit Carson Middle School. I suggest it be renamed Rachel Carson Middle School:

"Carson was also a man of contradictions and an agent of genocide. Although he married two Indigenous women and spoke several Indigenous languages, he fought, killed, and starved thousands of Apache and Navajo people during his military campaigns. He was an illiterate person who, in addition to Indigenous languages, mastered Spanish and French; and he was a man of unassuming appearance, short in stature with a quiet voice, who earned a reputation as a ruthless adversary." (https://coloradoencyclopedia.org/article/kit-carson)

Todd Edelman

Woah, I'm very curious how any newer streets get named, e.g. all the ones in the Cannery or parts of Mace Ranch -- do the developers just show up with a list? How are these lists generated? How can a private developer name parts of the fully public right-of-way after their children or deceased companion animals? Or a lovely Greenbelt after their mother-in-law? Do these people have parties, do weird drugs that us peasants don't yet know about, and randomly generate street names out of lists of people who share their love of golf and hunting in Rhodesia?

What if we start a petition to name streets in Not Benetton Woods "Murdered Trees Lane"? "Slimy Street"? "Bait and Switch Boulevard"? "Davis Buyers Club Just Kidding Alley"?

Perhaps we just go to numbers and letters - for which we have a start? Education is good, controversy not so much, honoring racists certainly bad. Another idea is to name streets after the places they head to, such as is common in Europe and perhaps some older or east coast towns? So in Davis we'd have e.g. "Winters Blvd" (formerly Russell) or Woodland Boulevard (formerly Pole Line).

How does all of this naming or re-naming adapt to technology for both orientation (e.g. Google Maps) and education (augmented reality apps that would show a simulation of General Montgomery defeating Rommel in front of Montgomery Elementary School)?

Todd Edelman

General Montgomery > Field General.... Monty.

Midge Ddorn

Maybe we should just stick with numbers and letters so as not to honor the wrong people or the person we currently feel is the right person. Maybe in 10 9r 20 years the "right person" will do or say something dispicable and we'll want to change the name again. Changing the name means changing maps and people's address. I would agree with some of the changes y people who did really horrible and well known things. In my experience, the names of streets and roads usually come from the developers and may require approval by a commissiion.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)