Free Speech Curtailed in Davis
Hundreds Expected for May Day Protests in Davis, Woodland and West Sacramento

DAVIS FREE SPEECH THREATENED

Photos show how community & political group tabling is dying in Farmer Market’s in its new park location.

By Alan “Lorax” Hirsch  [email protected]

Community and political groups have been removed from tabling in the Farmers Market along the C street sidewalk to an isolated unshaded part of Central Park. This happened by edict on 4/22/25, a decision made with no community groups’ input. Groups are concerned there would be no foot traffic in new location…and make it a waste of their time to table. The city manager said 30+ people that do the volunteer tabling should just give market manager’s idea “a try.” (LINK  to background piece)

The results are in from the first week of this experiment. Failure.

This is a photo at 11am (peak shopping) shows just 3 people visiting at the 7 tables of groups that took the time to set up in the unshaded and unpaved grassy part of the park near B Street. We heard from wheelchair bound shoppers that these tables were no longer accessible, like families with children in strollers.

2025-04-26 no visitors at community tables

It’s of note that only 7 groups set up tables compared to an average of 14/week for the previous month. No reason to waste volunteer time if no one comes by.

This is an especially striking result as the music and tables of the city’s Caesar Chavez day event on 4/26 (not pictured) should have attracted more shoppers to leave the C Street Market for the grassy area.   On a regular Saturday one would expect even less foot traffic to this area. 

Note also the children on the left in photo: tabling in this area intrudes into kids’ free play/family picnic area.

I passed out fliers and signs in the old location on Saturday for years, and my logs show I could give out 60-120 fliers any Saturday morning or 30-50 lawn signs, meaning 300-500 people would pass me.

This picture below is of market crowds when community groups were in the old location on the C street sidewalk.  First is a picture crowds in area in October 2016; you can just see the head of a Hillary cut out at Democratic table in the center of photo in the background where I was tabling.

2016 10 crowd at free speech area

City Claims Public  Speech Rights in Park were sold to Farmers Market, INC

 City is telling public in emails that it has no responsibility for free speech in Central Park or public C Street sidewalk as it has privatized our free speech rights to the Central Park by leasing it to Farmers Market, Inc. for 30 years in a no-bid contract. The trouble is that the city regulates speech in their municipal code at 14.070.01; this section could be changed.  And while city claims it privatized away public rights to have say on our  speech via a lease to the Market, Inc  this argument is inconsistent as city retains right (and cost) of policing the park, and continues to regulate consumption of alcohol on the now so-called privately regulated space by municipal ordinance- in muni code. And even specify the3 types of people who should be on the Market, Inc.  So this argument --we signed away all power -- seems like city is passing the buck—and one wonders if the  city would have a defensible position in court due to these inconsistencies.

But even before troubling: why is our city council not going to bat for small community groups who need the best possible access to the park & the market?   Why are they not stepping up to represent the  community seeing as the Davis Farmer Market Alliance, Inc’s board is self perpetuating and not accountable in any way.  And with 26 more years to run on their lease of the market space, the city seem to claimed it has no power via a threat of not renewing their seemingly unchecked monopoly power .

Community groups and individuals are planning to show up at Tuesday May 6th city council meeting to make their concerns known in verbal. Voice mail and written comment. [email protected].

The Davis Farmer Market Alliance Inc, board is does not publicly announce its meeting or have a public meeting schedule, publish agenda or its minutes or share it finances, and does have an board specific email on its website where public can give it input, or a place where the public can share its concerns.

2025 04 26 new group tabling area hidden

20250426 pix dead c street former group area

Comments

Roberta L. Millstein

The Enterprise is reporting that the Free Speech area is moving back. Well done Alan Hirsch and others for making noise.

"Following feedback from participants including concerns about ADA accessibility, no shade, less foot traffic, fewer booths, no consultation beforehand, inadequate time to prepare for the new accommodations and more, Davis Farmers Market executive director Randii MacNear says that beginning this Saturday, May 3, the free speech area will be moved back to its original location along the C Street sidewalk."

https://www.davisenterprise.com/news/davis-farmers-market-free-speech-area-to-move-back-to-c-street-following-concerns/article_96ce7c0b-9558-47b7-8e99-d7e6e253ea64.html

Alan Lorax

This is good obviously correct result. We have to fight for things we treasure -in Davis-and Bationslly.

The amazing Saturday Market is one of them.

. But Reporter did not explore what was really going on here:, The enterprise piece quotes Randii MacNear the a lack of space as reason for move the area is at capacity with 20 groups showing up.

BUT, In fact, I have a photograph of free speach sign in sheet from 6/2/2018 That indicates we had 39 groups tabling that day..

Opportunity lost by reporter.

Please note the enterprise reporter only talked with Randii when writing her article.about the Market controversy. When you only interview one side in a controversy — and those are the people in power—the name for the piece of writing is a “press release”.

Keith

Yay, Beth Bourne gets her free speech podium back.

Alan C. Miller

Not helping, KO!

Alan C. Miller

"When you only interview one side in a controversy — and those are the people in power—the name for the piece of writing is a “press release”.

True dat!

McNear acted quick enough to reverse this before it did become a full blown controversy and was able to get the official line out there in the "main stream media" (of Davis). So official line it is.

South of Davis

Did anyone hear "why" the "people in power" made the move? Was it to get Beth (and her "wrongspeech") away from the food booths or is someone mad at the "round earth denier"?

Tuvia etc

Great News!

I hope that people will become interested in a discussion about reallocating the curb to curb space on C Street between 3rd and 4th...

Alan C. Miller

TE, you are an author. Write an article and facilitate a discussion. Hint: include a map that shows current situation and what you are proposing. No one understands issues like this from text descriptions.

Alan C. Miller

SOD say: "Did anyone hear "why" the "people in power" made the move? Was it to get Beth (and her "wrongspeech") away from the food booths or is someone mad at the "round earth denier"? "

BB was out there doing her thing in the new area as well on the one day it was there. There is a booth that at least on some occasions had "art" that could be considered antisemitic. Some has inferred there was hope that person may 'go away' if they weren't getting attention at the new location. There was a popcorn truck in the location of the Free Speech Area along the curb, so some thought this was for expansion of food trucks. AP said above the Farmer's Market board is a closed book, so difficult to say to what degree these or other issues were the real cause, unless you are prone to believe the 'press release'.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)